Tag Cloud

BlogCumulus.net by Ryan Tomlinson and Roy Tanck requires Flash 9 and javascript

Recent Comments

Comment RSS

Top Commenters

Work Pants Work Pants
1 comments
us United States
TJ TJ
1 comments
us United States
Nicholas Overstreet Nicholas Overstreet
1 comments
us United States
Disclaimer
The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in any way.

© Copyright 2010 Nodnarb.Net

Screen Protector for my 50D ? Part 2

by Brandon July 7, 2009 01:55 AM

My blog post and my YouTube video for installing the GGS LCD screen protector have had a lot of views over the past few days. Thanks to all who read the blog and watched the video!

This is the second part of the story. In the first post, I showed you how to install the GGS LCD screen protector and gave a comparison of how it looked before and after on my Canon 50D. This time, I?ll show you my Canon 50D (with screen protector) compared side-by-side with my girlfriend?s camera, the Canon Digital Rebel T1i(Canon 500D). While it?s not quite an apples-to-apples comparison (I don?t know anyone else with a 50D), I think it will be close enough. I?m not a pro reviewer, after all smile_regular

In the photo below, you?ll see the 50D and the T1i sitting beside each other while indoors. The sample image, taken with the T1i and the EF-S 10-22 mm lens,  is displayed on both cameras. The image is nice and bright on both units when viewed indoors. The only light source for this room was the outside window.

Side by side comparison of Canon 50D with the GGS Screen Protector vs Canon Rebel T1i sans screen protector

I took the cameras outside just a little after 4:40 p.m. The sun was bright and there were a few scattered clouds, but not enough to affect this test. Looking at the photo below, I think you?ll agree with me that images on an LCD screen are hard to see whether or not the GGS LCD screen protector is installed. The sample image may not be perfect, but I can tell you from looking at them in person that they were both hard to see in the sunlight. The LCDs on both cameras are at their default brightness, by the way.

Outside side-by-side comparison of the Canon 50D with screen protector vs the Canon T1i sans screen protector

Because neither LCD was very viewable in direct sunlight, I decided to get another shot of them. This time, I turned my back to the sunlight and shaded them with my torso and head, just like anyone else may do when trying to review a shot on a bright day. In my opinion, both images look good. You can see some reflection from my T-shirt on the 50D with the screen protector. I didn?t get a shot of me holding the T1i against my T-shirt, however. From my experience in comparing the two cameras, my guess is the T1i would also show the reflection, maybe just not as prominent as the 50D. On both cameras, you can discern the tree, horizon, sky and clouds in the display image.

GGSOutsideShaded

In the final picture, below, both cameras are compared again. This time, no image is being displayed on the LCDs. Here, just like the video from the first post, you can see the 50D with the GGS LCD screen protector is more reflective when no image is displayed. Concentrate on the green grass in the background of the display image. Look at the T1i next. While both screens are clearly reflecting the table, you cannot see the grass with the anti-reflective coating on the T1i?s screen. This result could have a little to do with the angle at which the comparison image was shot, but I think you?d definitely see grass on the T1i if it also had a screen protector installed.

Side by side comparison of the 50D with screen protector vs the T1i without screen protector. No image is displayed on either LCD.

CONCLUSION:

Installing a LCD screen protector on your digital camera, like the GGS LCD screen protector, may introduce some unwanted reflection. I thought the amount of reflection was negligible, though, when I viewed an image both indoors and outdoors. If you?re considering a LCD screen protector for your camera, keep your eyesight in mind and think about how much this might bother you. I have good eyesight and wasn?t bothered at all. The main thing to ponder, though, is how you use your camera and if you think you are accident-prone enough to scratch or crack your LCD screen. If you only take the camera out at holidays and other special occasions, it might not be worth it. If you find an excuse to drag your camera everywhere, like me, it may be worth the price. I bought this $9 accessory to possibly save myself an expensive repair in the future. I?ve weighed the pros and cons and will keep the screen protector on my 50D for now. If I decided to remove it, or if it saves me from a nasty scratch, I?ll be sure to post about it.

Thanks for reading my posts about the LCD screen protector. If I helped you make a decision on whether or not to purchase one for yourself, please leave a comment!

Tags: , , , ,

Photography

Comments

July 8, 2009 11:06 AM
Nicholas Overstreet
Wait... which camera did you use to take THESE pictures?!
July 8, 2009 11:12 AM
brandon
June's point and shoot (Sony DSC-T100, I think)
July 19, 2009 05:01 PM
KrAzE
Oh man, after lenses and everything, this camera costs more than the most expensive thing I own...
United States Staci 
July 27, 2009 11:19 PM
Staci
Thanks for this, I appreciate the work you put into creating this review!! Smile
United States attok 
October 28, 2009 10:55 PM
attok
Hi,

it's good information

i have 50D, i bought include plastic screen protector (ZEIKEOS)
i installed and air bubble appear Frown

I order the other one Lexerd - Canon EOS-50D TrueVue Crystal Clear Digital Camera Screen Protector.

my question is
1. is it good enough for my LCD?
2. which one the best
Lexerd - Canon EOS-50D TrueVue Crystal Clear Digital Camera Screen ProtectoR vs GGS DSLR LCD Optical Glass Screen Protector for Canon EOS 50D Mark II Digital SLR Cameras ?

Big THX
October 29, 2009 02:47 AM
brandon
Hi! I looked up the Lexerd screen protector on Amazon.com. This type of screen protector is available for many smart phones also. I don't like this type because they can get bubbles, which is what happened to you. I also don't like them because they don't protect against an object with a hard corner or hard point hitting the LCD screen. This could happen if the camera hit the side of a table or if it hits your belt buckle while carrying the camera. The film-type protectors are easier to replace and can protect against minor scratches, but they don't protect as well against the examples I listed above. I have used the glass GGS protector for a few months now and still like it a lot.
United States attok 
October 28, 2009 11:43 PM
attok
thx for info,


is those "glass" material held by adhesive around all corners?
October 29, 2009 02:40 AM
brandon
Yes, it is. It seals around the LCD screen protector so dust/dirt cannot enter and get between the camera LCD and the screen protector.
October 30, 2009 09:54 AM
trackback
Screen Protector for my 50D

Screen Protector for my 50D
United States TJ 
February 6, 2010 02:13 AM
TJ
Just a quick question. do you remove the film thats on the canon prior to installing this or do you just leave it on?
February 6, 2010 11:48 AM
Brandon
Mine didn't come with a film already on it. Did you buy your camera used? If there's any kind of third party film/protector, you definitely want to remove it before installing a protector like this one.

Add comment


(Will show your Gravatar icon)

  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading